In a jaw-dropping moment that has shaken up the world of college football, Fernando Mendoza has just snatched the coveted Heisman Trophy, marking a historic win that leaves fans divided and debating. This isn't just any award—it's college football's ultimate honor, given to the player deemed the nation's best, and Mendoza's victory is a game-changer for Indiana and beyond. But here's where it gets controversial: Is this rising star the true standout, or does the trend of quarterback dominance say more about the game's shifting priorities? Stick around, because we're diving deep into the details that make this story so captivating.
New York (AP) — Fernando Mendoza, the enigmatic quarterback steering the mighty No. 1 Indiana squad, claimed the Heisman Trophy on Saturday evening, etching his name as the first Hoosier to secure college football's most elite accolade since its launch back in 1935.
Mendoza dominated the voting with an impressive 2,362 first-place nods, edging out Vanderbilt's signal-caller Diego Pavia (who garnered 1,435 votes), Notre Dame's dynamic running back Jeremiyah Love (719 votes), and Ohio State's talented quarterback Julian Sayin (432 votes).
Under Mendoza's leadership, the Hoosiers soared to their inaugural No. 1 spot and clinched the top seed in the expansive 12-team College Football Playoff bracket (for full details, check out https://apnews.com/article/college-football-playoff-bracket-7ea3841a2f3309d0f4eb0b5dbc835ee5). He racked up 2,980 passing yards and a record-setting 33 touchdown throws, all while dashing for six more scores on the ground. Indiana, standing tall as the sole undefeated powerhouse in major college football, gears up for a thrilling College Football Playoff quarterfinal clash in the iconic Rose Bowl on January 1.
Mendoza, stepping into his role as the Hoosiers' starter for the first time after a big move from California, serves as the sparkplug for an attack that demolished previous program milestones for touchdowns and total points, achieved during their surprising charge into the CFP last year. As a redshirt junior and a Miami native who wasn't heavily courted initially (for more on his journey, see https://apnews.com/article/indiana-hoosiers-heisman-trophy-ee391a38a298c88cb85dd259a3613382), Mendoza joins the ranks as only the second Heisman finalist in Indiana's history, alongside 1989 runner-up Anthony Thompson. He's also one of seven Hoosiers to crack the top 10 in Heisman voting, and this achievement cements another program first: consecutive players in the top 10, following quarterback Kurtis Rourke's ninth-place finish last year.
Quarterbacks have swept the Heisman in four of the past five seasons, with Colorado's versatile two-way player Travis Hunter breaking the streak last year (dive into that story at https://apnews.com/article/heisman-trophy-travis-hunter-colorado-c76c411ca04108018eefb18beaa649fe). And this is the part most people miss: Is this QB monopoly a sign of modern football's evolution, where aerial assaults reign supreme, or a nod to the growing importance of transfer portals that allow stars like Mendoza to switch teams and redefine their legacies?
The Heisman ceremony followed a flurry of other honors. Mendoza snagged The Associated Press Player of the Year title earlier in the week (https://apnews.com/article/ap-player-of-year-c74829567a6d158eb90a821e512ad281) and added the Maxwell and Davey O’Brien Awards on Friday night (https://apnews.com/article/college-football-awards-cd6f46b116d0bfa35f5c762dc1aa708b), while Love took home the Doak Walker Award.
Confident Commodore
Pavia, standing at a modest 6 feet, orchestrated Vanderbilt's offense to new heights, hurling a program-record 3,192 yards and 27 touchdowns for the Commodores, who battled fiercely for a CFP invitation right up to the bracket reveal. He's the pioneering Heisman finalist in Vanderbilt's storied past.
The self-described Albuquerque, New Mexico, native, who identifies as "a chip on the shoulder guy," embodies brash confidence both on and off the field. His path to stardom was unconventional: from no high school recruits to junior college, New Mexico State, and finally Vanderbilt via the transfer portal in 2024. Pavia steered the Commodores to their maiden 10-win campaign and six triumphs over Southeastern Conference rivals, including four against ranked foes, propelling them to a No. 9 perch—their loftiest spot in The Associated Press Top 25 (https://apnews.com/hub/ap-top-25-college-football-poll) since 1937.
But here's where it gets intriguing—and potentially divisive: Pavia is currently playing his fourth Division I season under a preliminary injunction (https://apnews.com/article/vanderbilt-diego-pavia-preliminary-injunction-2025-029ed63d2520a2930be197d31ccc0e5f), challenging NCAA eligibility rules by arguing that his junior college time shouldn't count toward his clock, citing potential earnings losses from name, image, and likeness opportunities as an unfair curb on free enterprise. Is this a bold stand for athletes' rights, potentially reshaping college sports, or a loophole that could tilt the playing field unfairly? It's a debate that's heating up.
Vanderbilt's next stop is the ReliaQuest Bowl against Iowa on December 31.
Buckeyes’ leader
Sayin propelled Ohio State to a dominant No. 1 ranking for much of the season, amassing 3,329 passing yards and tying for second nationally with 31 touchdown passes, setting the stage for their CFP quarterfinal in the Cotton Bowl on December 31.
This sophomore from Carlsbad, California, landed at Ohio State after initially pledging to Alabama and entering the transfer portal amid a coaching shake-up. He saw action in four games last year before seizing the starter role, guiding the Buckeyes to a resounding 14-7 victory over preseason favorite Texas in the opener and maintaining their AP Top 25 supremacy for 13 consecutive weeks, matching their second-longest such streak.
Sayin stands out as just the second Bowl Subdivision quarterback in the last 40 years to boast three games in a single season with 300-plus yards passing, three touchdowns, zero interceptions, and an 80% or better completion rate—joining West Virginia's Geno Smith from 2012. He follows in the footsteps of Ohio State's quarterback lineage under coach Ryan Day since 2017, where predecessors like Dwayne Haskins (2018), Justin Fields (2019), C.J. Stroud (2021), and Kyle McCord (2023) racked up an average of 3,927 yards, 40 touchdowns, six interceptions, and a 68.9% completion rate in their debut seasons. For beginners wondering about the transfer portal, it's like a modern marketplace where players can switch schools to find better fits, sparking debates on whether it levels the playing field or creates an unfair advantage.
Irish Love
The last running back to hoist the Heisman was Alabama's Derrick Henry back in 2015. Yet, Love thrust himself into contention with a remarkable campaign for Notre Dame.
The junior from St. Louis ranked fourth in the Bowl Subdivision for rushing yards (1,372), fifth in per-game output (114.3), and third in rushing touchdowns (18) for the Fighting Irish, who narrowly missed a CFP spot and chose to skip bowl participation.
Love became the first Notre Dame player ever to record multiple touch-down runs of 90 yards or longer, including a 98-yarder versus Indiana in last year's playoff opener and a 94-yarder against Boston College this season. He bolstered his Heisman case with mesmerizing feats—like keeping his footing while leaping over defenders, twirling out of tackles, or shedding would-be tacklers. Pairing up with Jadarian Price, they formed one of the year's premier rushing tandems, aiding rookie starter CJ Carr in blossoming into a top young quarterback. This highlights a fascinating counterpoint: While quarterbacks dominate headlines, could the Heisman's focus on passers overlook the raw power and creativity of running backs like Love, who redefine what it means to control the game on the ground?
Get poll alerts and updates on the AP Top 25 throughout the season. Sign up here (https://www.apnews.com/newsletters). AP college football: https://apnews.com/hub/ap-top-25-college-football-poll and https://apnews.com/hub/college-football
What do you think—does Fernando Mendoza's win prove that quarterbacks are the undisputed kings of college football, or is it high time to celebrate the unsung heroes like running backs in the Heisman spotlight? And about those eligibility challenges, like Pavia's: Do they empower athletes or risk unbalancing the sport? Share your hot takes, agreements, or disagreements in the comments—we're all ears!
