West Ham United is at a crossroads, with the manager's seat feeling increasingly unstable. Nuno Espirito Santo's tenure at West Ham is under serious scrutiny, raising questions about his future at the club. After taking over in September, replacing Graham Potter, the team's performance hasn't improved, leaving fans and analysts concerned. The Hammers' position in the Premier League table mirrors the bleakness of four months ago, and the impact expected of Nuno at the London Stadium hasn't materialized.
Since Nuno's appointment, West Ham's performance has been disappointing. They haven't secured a win since November 8th, and in the 15 Premier League games he's managed, they've only earned 11 points. The style of play has been criticized, and there's a sense that the players aren't fully engaged, which is a worrying sign for the team's morale.
But here's where it gets controversial...
Given the team's struggles, the possibility of Nuno being sacked is being discussed. This has led to speculation about potential replacements, with Michael Carrick being a prominent name linked to the role. TalkSPORT reports that Carrick is high on West Ham's list, and former boss Slaven Bilic is also being considered for a potential short-term role. Carrick was also a potential replacement for David Moyes when he left the club in May 2024.
Carrick's time at Middlesbrough saw him implement an appealing, possession-based style of play. However, the team failed to secure promotion to the Premier League, and he was let go in June 2025 after finishing 10th in the Championship. Overall, in 139 games as a manager, Carrick has a win rate of 47%, with 25 draws and 49 losses.
And this is the part most people miss...
Carrick is a familiar figure to West Ham fans, having played for the club for six years before joining Tottenham in 2004. He was well-liked by the fans until he left for Tottenham.
Appointing Carrick would be a gamble for West Ham due to his lack of extensive experience in football management. At this point, securing consistent wins and earning points is what matters most. Nuno is in a better position to achieve this at West Ham compared to Carrick. Carrick has been without a job since his time at Middlesbrough, which speaks volumes. If the owners are considering a short-term managerial change, they need someone who can help the team avoid relegation.
What do you think? Would Michael Carrick be the right choice for West Ham? Do you agree that the team needs a manager who can secure wins, or is an attractive style of play more important? Share your thoughts and opinions in the comments below!
