The Cubs' Infield Conundrum: A Tale of Talent and Tough Choices
In a bold move, the Chicago Cubs secured star third baseman Alex Bregman, a multi-time All-Star, for the upcoming 2026 season. Bregman's arrival, however, has sparked a debate about the future of the team's infielders. With a strong 2025 season, the Cubs boasted regulars at every infield position, but the addition of Bregman has created an intriguing dilemma.
The Infield Logjam
Dansby Swanson and Nico Hoerner have been a solid shortstop and second base duo for three consecutive seasons. Meanwhile, Matt Shaw, the team's top prospect, emerged as a regular at third base in 2025. The arrival of Bregman now leaves the Cubs with four infielders for three positions.
One potential solution is utilizing the designated hitter spot. With Kyle Tucker's expected departure, Seiya Suzuki could see more outfield action in 2026. However, Moises Ballesteros, who had a promising debut in 2025, is currently favored for the DH role, despite being considered a work in progress behind the plate.
Trading Scenarios: Unraveling the Infield Puzzle
While having an abundance of talented players is a good problem to have, it raises the question: Will the Cubs make a move to address this logjam?
If no trade occurs, Shaw might be the odd man out. He has options remaining and could be sent to Triple-A Iowa, but he could also be a utility player on the bench. Hoerner, set to hit free agency after the 2026 season, might be the most likely candidate to move, with Shaw taking a depth role this year and potentially transitioning to second base when Hoerner departs.
The Risks and Rewards of Inaction
This plan, however, has its flaws. Shaw, at just 24, showed considerable power potential in the second half of 2025, but inconsistent playing time or minor league competition could hinder his development. The Cubs' coaching staff noted that Shaw underwent several mechanical changes throughout the year, and his performance dipped in the final weeks of the season, suggesting there's still work to be done.
Trading Hoerner or Shaw: A Viable Option?
Hoerner's name has been mentioned as a trade candidate in recent offseasons, and it's easy to see why. The 28-year-old had a career year in 2025, posting impressive numbers and demonstrating elite defense at second base. He's been a consistent producer, with an above-average wRC+ in every season since becoming an everyday player.
Hoerner's value to the team is undeniable, with a cumulative 19.6 bWAR and 17.5 fWAR over the past four seasons. His affordable $12MM salary this year makes him an attractive trade target for other teams.
The Cubs' Stance: Unlikely to Trade Hoerner
Despite interest from teams like the Mariners, Giants, and Yankees, the Cubs seem reluctant to part with Hoerner. Trading him after signing Bregman would undermine the very improvement they sought. The Athletic's Sahadev Sharma suggests the Cubs would only consider trading Hoerner if they were 'blown away' by an offer.
Trading Shaw: A Potential Solution?
Trading Shaw to a team where he could get consistent playing time might be the best course of action. With six years of team control remaining and a league-minimum salary in 2026, Shaw could be an attractive option for teams looking to upgrade their offense on a budget. Teams like the Pirates, Guardians, Royals, Athletics, Angels, and Nationals, who struggled at second or third base last year, could benefit from Shaw's talent and affordability.
The Risks of Trading Shaw
However, trading Shaw comes with risks. His value might be lower compared to last year, when he was considered a top-30 prospect in baseball. Additionally, trading Shaw without an extension for Hoerner would be a big risk, given Hoerner's impending free agency. The upcoming free agent class has depth in middle infield talent, but landing one of those players is not guaranteed.
The Cubs' internal options behind Shaw are also lacking. James Triantos, once a promising prospect, had a disastrous Triple-A season, and Jefferson Rojas, while solid in 2025, might not be major league-ready by 2027.
The Cubs' Infield Future: Your Thoughts?
How do you think the Cubs should navigate this infield situation? Should they trade Shaw or Hoerner before Opening Day, or is it better to keep both and address the playing time issue later? Cast your vote and share your thoughts in the poll below!
